2. SMU’s miracle game-tying two-point conversion
SMU needed a two-point conversion to tie the game against Rutgers and I’m sure this is exactly how the coaching staff drew it up on the sidelines right beforehand. Garrett Gilbert spent the entire time running for his life and then threw a fade away pass across the field to Jeremy Johnson, who somehow hauled the pass in. This two-point conversion was nothing short of a miracle and would be #1 if it weren’t for the Iron Bowl.